Q13

User avatar
 
WaltGrace1983
Thanks Received: 207
Atticus Finch
Atticus Finch
 
Posts: 837
Joined: March 30th, 2013
 
 
trophy
Most Thanked
trophy
Most Thankful
trophy
First Responder
 

Q13

by WaltGrace1983 Tue Jun 10, 2014 11:46 am

This question is asking us why the author quotes Fruton at the end. This seems like a good question to pre-phrase. We know that Fruton was all about competition, saying that it was a good thing that would lead to other good things! Does the author feel the same way? Yea! I think he/she does! We get some subtle hints of the author's voice at the beginning of the final paragraph, when he/she states that "interaction..can have important results...progress was fueled by competition..."

The placement of the quote also seems important. The quote comes right after we get these subtle hints of the author's opinion. It seems that Fruton was used to emphasize the author's subtle point or, if we don't really know if the author really feels so strongly about competition, Fruton was used to emphasize the main point of the article.

    (A) seems great!

    (B) First of all, Fruton's quote is more abstract and less concerned with cytology and biochemistry in specific. In addition, there really isn't any "new evidence" being presented. We would have little reason to believe that the LSAT would give us a brand new piece of information and leave us with a cliffhanger :D

    (C) No way! The biochemists are long gone! We are dealing with the abstract here!

    (D) Nah. Fruton is emphasizing the GOOD encountered when two disciplines compete. Also, Fruton is not really talking about "synthesis" of disciplines. In fact, he is talking about when disciplines are polarizing.

    (E) Like (C), this is just flat out wrong.


(A) is clearly the best answer and, if we didn't know the Author's opinion before, we certainly do now!