cdjmarmon Wrote:I too got rid of C becuase I saw it as out of scope. I did see it as a good strengthen answer though. Which further made me get rid of it because I saw it as more of a trick answer that sounds appealing but wouldnt resolve the paradox.
Im curious where the comparison between the healthy eating and non healthy eating mothers is at?
The stimulus discusses a recommendation that pregnant women eat a nutritious diet, and the discrepancy is that their babies still get sick. So, discussing those pregnant women that don't eat that diet is within scope. It's like me suggesting that people study for the LSAT with a hat on. If you want to evaluate that in some way, it's totally reasonable to bring in the topic of people that study for the LSAT without a hat on.
(C) does strengthen the recommendation, and it does that in great part by neutralizing the possible counter premise (that the babies of the nutritious-diet moms get sick).
That make sense now?