RC - Refrence RC 99

[sidd.shah123]

How to approach such passage with extreme details I tend to forget what i read and cant figure out what each para tries to say or the main point ?



The combination of consonant-vowel syllabic glyphs and logographs in ancient Mayan gave the scribes a variety of choices with which to write the words of their texts in detail. For example, one very common honorific title in Maya texts is ahaw, meaning "•lord"– or "•noble."– Ahaw
may be written in logographic form as a head in profile, with the distinctive headband or scarf that marked the highest nobility in Maya society. But it is also possible to write the word as a combination of three phonetic, syllabic signs: a-ha-wa. Likewise, the word pakal ("•shield"–) can be indicated by a depiction of a shield or by the combination of syllabic
elements pa-ka-la.


Mayan signs are by nature highly pictorial, often representing in
considerable detail animals, people, body parts and objects of daily life. The pictorial principle is taken to the extreme in inscriptions composed of "•full-figure"– glyphs, in which individual signs and numbers become animated and are shown interacting with one another. None of this should be taken to mean that the Maya only wrote in simple pictures. The
Maya wrote both logographically and phonetically, and within their phonetic system alone, the Maya had multiple options. All English words are formed from various combinations of only 26 phonetic signs. By contrast, all Maya words can be formed from various combinations of nearly 800 consonant-vowel glyphs, each representing a full syllable. Sounds are formed by combining a particular consonant with one of the
five vowels (hence a syllabary, rather than an alphabet).

Because many Maya signs remain undeciphered, it"˜s not possible to state precisely the relative proportions of logographic and syllabic signs. But a significant number of the logograms have been deciphered and the number of deciphered syllabic signs keeps growing. Epigraphers have filled more than half of the syllabic grid, meant to plot the consonants of
the spoken Maya language against its vowels and thus represents the totality of signs needed to write the language. It must be remembered that the discovery of the structure of the syllabic elements"”Knorozov"˜s main contribution"”was made a little more than 30 years ago. Furthermore, the consonant-vowel syllables that are already understood
are the common ones.

Nonetheless, the pace of phonetic decipherment is bound to increase in the coming years as more resources are trained on it. One aspect of Maya writing that may complicate this progress is the fact that different signs can be allographs. Such equivalences are common in Maya texts (there are at least five different signs that could be chosen to represent
the Maya syllable ba). Each scribe chose from several different signs to convey the sounds. In evaluating a particular phonetic interpretation of a syllable, it"˜s helpful to identify as many as possible of the variant forms; so the process of recognizing allographs depends on the slow work of comparing many texts in order to find variant spellings of the same word.



here are the questions:

1. The author mentions Knorozov in the third paragraph in order to:
A. prove that the recent discovery of Maya signs has led to its lack of
decipherment.
B. offer an explanation for what may appear to be a relative paucity in
the completion of the Maya sign syllabic grid.
C. argue that expert linguists have been stymied in their attempts to
decipher and understand many allographic Maya signs.
D. show how the understanding of other linguistic structures may
improve the comprehension of Maya syllabic signs.
E. weaken the argument stated in the previous paragraph


2. As used in the passage by the author, the term "•logographic"– most closely
refers to:
A. a written phonetic representation of a word.
B. a syllabic division of an individual word.
C. an imagistic representation of an idea.
D. a visual picture of an idiomatic phrase.
E. the process of designing a logo



3. The author of the passage would be LEAST likely to agree with which of the
following statements?
A. Languages whose writing is composed of pictorial signs can
demonstrate a remarkable degree of complexity and detail.
B. Linguistic signs based on syllabic or phonetic coding may be easier to
decipher than those based on visual images.
C. Logographic languages are restricted to the expression of simple
ideas because of their emphasis on image.
D. The existence of allographs in Maya signs indicates the complexity of
this linguistic system.
E. The Mayans made use of both logographics as well as phonetics

[george.kourdin]

if its any concellation I found this RC to be tough....

1) - pretty much the worst. nothing seems right. ended up picking B, not knowing what paucity is, but hoping that it means something along the lines "small progress/improvement"
a - he isn't proving anything
c - dont think he is arguing either and it doesnt seem like thats the purpose of that statement + we don't know whether he is an expert linguist
d - prob right choice now that i look back at it
e - just no

2) logographic has to deal with an image so everything related to words goes out the window

a) no
b) no
c) contended but that is one ugly way to mask the meaning of logographic but okay
d) contended but not sure whether idiomatic phrase is correct
e) not a process and logo is wrong

chose c over d because i was under the imperssion that it doesn't relate to phrases. you can also use symbols to draw a word/idea therefore d is wrong/too narrow

3) another absurd question. either b or c. i went with b.
a) no
b) contender
c) contender
d) no
e) no
d)

[miju_mvr]

gud post

[sidd.shah123]

Can i have experts opinion please?

[jnelson0612]

Will you please provide the original source of this passage and questions?

[akhpad]

Aristotle Prep RC - 99

[tim]

to answer your question, you need to focus on a reading strategy that specifically bypasses the minute details and instead focuses on more of a big picture with significant attention to passage structure. this process is described in incredible detail in our reading comprehension strategy guide. try the strategies in that guide and then let us know if you have more questions..