by RonPurewal Sun May 18, 2014 10:33 am
This is entirely an issue of meaning/context.
"Supposed(ly)", in this sense, refers to something that is reputed to be true, but is doubted by someone. So, it just depends on what you actually doubt.
For instance, let's say someone hands me a cookie, claiming that it's gluten-free, but I doubt that it's actually gluten-free.
Then this would be a supposedly gluten-free cookie, because the quality of being gluten-free is the only thing that is actually in doubt here.
On the other hand, let's say someone claims to have a magical cookie that will cure all illnesses and pains"”but claims to have left the magical cookie at home. I, of course, doubt the existence of this supposed magical cookie altogether.
In other words, I don't think that it exists at all.